mtunionlogo2.gif (2820 bytes)

www.MtUnionFootball.com

  Main Page             Email

RAIDBLK.gif (1849 bytes)  

Game of the Millennium

                    October 2, 1999                         by Dick Ross

A SHORT JOURNEY THROUGH TIME

     Autumn officially began on September 20.  Northern Ohio, the past week, has been a study in contrasts with overnight temperatures dipping into the 40's and daytime highs up into the 80's.  We've had an assortment of cold rain, thunderstorms and several beautiful days.  Saturday began with a few high clouds, 70 degree temperatures and brilliant sunshine.

  Mount Union  57      John Carroll  51
Triple Overtime

     Mount Union Football comes to Cleveland once a year, either to Berea (B-W) or University Heights; the one time each year that my trip is shorter than the players, coaches and fans coming from Alliance.   While John Carroll, in "the Heights," is a short and easy trip, in miles, from my home in Westlake, it tends to be a journey through time, for me, going back to the East Side, where I grew up. 

     Heading east on the Shoreway we pass Downtown and the new Cleveland Browns Stadium on the site where the old Municipal Stadium stood for 60 years; the site of many memories.  In 1931 Mount Union met John Carroll on this site: Carroll won 13-0 and No, I wasn't around for that one! 

     Although there are many bright new buildings along the way, Captain Frank's is gone from the East 9th Street Pier and the Steamer "William J. Mather" is now permanently moored to the quay, as a Museum.   From Muni Light to the C. E. I.  plant the Lake is a gray blue, with a slight chop and a few scattered sail boats.

99johncarroll.jpg (11249 bytes)     Towards East 55th Street the Nicholson Terminal Building, which once received automobiles from Detroit by boat, is now an empty skeleton, pending redevelopment.  The scheduled opening date is long since past.  Past East 72nd Street "Liberty Boulevard" is now "Martin Luther King" and has been for more than a generation.  The "Cultural Gardens" have been restored, but very few, of the original Sycamores remain.  Each tree had been planted with a brass plate commemorating a casualty of "The Great War."

     Exiting at East 152nd, the road passes up and over the yard throat of the Collinwood Yards.  The Collinwood Shops of the old New York Central once employed thousands here in railroading, and the maintenance, building and rebuilding of steam and electric locomotives, in the huge roundhouse and the
back shop buildings, across the street.  This is the spot where electric locomotives of the Cleveland Union Terminal replaced steam, for the trip downtown, under the Terminal Tower complex.  Only the electric shop, which now does work on diesels, and the immense concrete coaling tower remain; the coaling tower only because it would be to difficult and expensive to demolish.

     A few blocks further, is the intersection known as "Five Points," dominated by Collinwood High School, home of the "Railroaders" and Alma Mater of college roommate Jack Yoder.  Taking the "soft" left, to Ivanhoe, which becomes Belvoir Blvd., as we climb into the East Cleveland, we pass near Shaw High, the "Old School" of E. Karl Schneider, another "roomie" who is now a Trustee of the College.  Further along the Boulevard enters the South Euclid-Lyndhurst District, home of Brush High "Arcs" and site of Carroll's last victory over Mount, in 1989, 31-7.  Further up the hill we skirt the edge of my old neighborhood, in Cleveland Heights.  John Carroll played their home games at our field, on the corner of Cedar and Lee, during my years at Heights High.  With a bus pass, about a dollar in cash and nothing else to do on a Saturday, I remember attending one of those games during the early sixties, but I couldn't tell you the opponent or the score.

TODAY'S GAME

     I had planned to follow Belvoir up into the Carroll Campus, but found the streets clogged with cars and people, well short of the Stadium, even though it was still more than an hour to kick off.  The sidewalks were crowded with an interesting mix of people: Mount Union fans in Purple; Carroll fans in Blue and Yellow and Orthodox Jews, in Black, on their way home from Saturday services.  The Orthodox will neither drive, nor ride, in an automobile on their Sabbath Day.  The rest of us had merely abandoned our automobiles as
close as we could get to Wasmer Field.
99johncarroll1.jpg (5812 bytes)

     Walking up Belvoir the first building we come to is the "Don Shula Sports Complex."  A painting in the lobby portrays Shula as a Carroll player, as Coach of the Baltimore Colts and his days on the Miami Dolphins sidelines, surprisingly his years as a Browns and Colts player were not included.  Among other famous Carroll Alums is Tim Russert of NBC's "Meet the Press."

     The entrance to Wasmer Field is a very nice Tudor archway in the middle of a pair of modern dormitories.  You'd think that the ticket booths would be in the gateway and that the field would be directly beyond, but instead the "Balsam Artificial Turf" field is up the hill to the right, and the ticket booth is a plywood shack.  The real entrance to the stadium is a hole in the fence shared by all "fans" and both teams - the source of some troubles, in the past.  The home stands at JCU are high rise steel angle iron, with wooden seats.  The only rest rooms are in a brick building under the home stands; the very limited visitors seating, across the way, is also of wood and steel construction.
   
"INTENSE DISLIKE"

     For two teams who have played each other regularly only since 1989, the rivalry is amazing and can only be described as "Intense Dislike."   Mount is 9-1-1 in the recent series including the 1989 loss, a 1991 tie, and one post season game in 1997.  Last fall "Tony" DeCarlo stepped down after 12 seasons as a head coach to devote full time to his position as athletic director.   The new coach of the Blue Streaks is Regis Scafe whose coaching career included seven years as an assistant under DeCarlo, and four years as head coach at CWRU.  At least two of his graduate assistants have names familiar to Raider fans: Sean Gorius, brother of Ryan Gorius, running back on Mount's three most recent championship teams and Nick Caserio, JCU quarterback for the last several seasons.

     In spite of the intense rivalry, this week's "T" shirt contest had much more class than Ohio Northern's orange shirts of last Saturday.  Mount's cheerleaders were selling shirts which read: "The Streaks are Purple - Not Blue" listing Mount's championships and "Streaks."  JCU's shirts had representations of both team's helmets and "MUC vs. JCU: The Game of the Millennium."   They hadn't even guessed the half of it, when they were screening those shirts!

99johncarroll2.jpg (6337 bytes)     Today is Homecoming for the "Blue Streaks," cooking fires are burning at several locations around campus, many of the booths and activities are similar to the ones we saw last week, except for the beer tent on the tennis courts, west of the Stadium.  The Blue Streaks took the field wearing Notre Dame style gold helmets, gold trousers and blue jerseys with white numerals.  The Raiders arrived wearing purple pants and road white jerseys with purple numbers.  The teams were kept carefully separated to prevent a recurrence of the pre-kickoff brawl which preceded the last meeting in Cleveland, in 1996.

     John Carroll took the opening kickoff and ran the field in convincing style, #21 TB Bobby Kraft of Milwaukee dove the final yard of a seven-play 68-yard drive to open the scoring.   For the rest of the afternoon the two teams went toe to toe like heavyweight fighters, never separated by more than a touchdown.

     Mount's first drive sputtered after 33 yards and Carroll held the ball temporarily until # 19 QB Tom Arth, "Frosh" from Westlake/St Ignatius, fumbled.  After the ball was kicked or touched by half the men on the field Mount's # 49 Jr. LB Jesse Pearson of Columbus/Troy hauled it in and rumbled 33 yards for a TD.  Last week Pearson became the first defenseman in Raider history to score in two consecutive games: this week he extended his personal streak to three.  "Conversion" by # 1 Soph. Rodney Chenos of Galloway, Ohio, tied the score at seven.

     With the wind behind him, # 19 Sr. Brandon Bakos of North Royalton was able to contain Carroll's awesome kick returners by regularly putting the ball deep in the end zone.  JCU's next possession was a "three and out" and Mount was able to capitalize with runs by # 31 Soph. RB Dan Pugh of Norwalk and catches by # 10 Chuck Moore, Soph. RB from Mogadore, and # 9 Sr. Nate Chester of North Canton.  Dan's personal cheering section, led by his sister, was directly in front of me; I wasn't quite sure if they were "woofing" or yelling: "Pugh," "Pugh," "Pugh."  I'll ask next week!  The drive ran out of steam and downs at the 25-yard line but Chenos was able to put a "wind assisted" three pointer through the uprights with three seconds left in the quarter.

FIRST QUARTER SCORE:  MOUNT UNION 10, JOHN CARROLL 7

"WHO ARE THESE GUYS?"99johncarroll3.jpg (6751 bytes)

     The Blue Streaks opened the second period with an 11-play 63-yard drive that ended with a missed field goal at the Mount 17.  Mount held the ball for four plays until # 16 Soph. QB Gary Smeck of Lancaster suffered his second interception of the season.  Carroll's # 32, Sr. Tom Rini of Fairview Park made the pick and a 54-yard return to put his team ahead by four, 14-10.  Mount responded with a nine-play 71-yard drive, capped by a one-yard run by Dan Pugh to turn the score to 17-14, MUC.

     With the wind now behind the gold topped "Streaks," the next kickoff was run back to the Mount 30.  The saving tackle by the kicker Bakos postponed the Carroll TD by one play, Mount's lead held only 23 seconds: 21-17 JCU, with 5:58 to play.  After an unusual exchange of punts the "good guys," put on a nine-play 85-yard drive, using the clock, moving the sticks and dipping into the Kehres "bag of tricks" with a reverse to # 2, Jr.  Adam Marino of Cuyahoga Falls, finishing up with a two-yard TD run by Chuck Moore.  This put the Raiders up by three, again, and left only 36 seconds remaining in the half.  This is the point where Ohio Northern "took a knee" last week to end the half - not these guys.  Starting on their own 27, after a defensive bouncing Bakos kick off, the Streakers used three plays, including a "flea flicker" off of a reverse, to move to their own 44 with one-point-something seconds left.  Carroll QB Tom Arth took the snap, ran left, then right, then wound up and threw a REAL "Hail Mary" to the right corner of the end zone.  At least eight players, from both teams, surrounded the ball, it bounced above them once, then twice, then Larry Holmes, of Cleveland/St. Edward, # 85 in Blue, came down with the ball, well after time expired.  This time Mount's lead lasted for 36 seconds and it was the home team going into the locker room with a four point lead.

HALF TIME SCORE:  JOHN CARROLL 28,  MOUNT UNION 24

     The third quarter turned into a defensive slugfest.   Mount's best drive so far ran out of downs on the JCU two-yard line, with six minutes left.  Carroll made it only to their own 11 before they punted back.   Ominously it began to cloud up and get cooler as Mount stalled, but hit "restart" with a fake punt, taken by #3 Soph. DB Todd Smargiasso of New Wilmintgon, Pa.  Todd entered his name on the "all time" rushing list with one carry of 17 yards and a first down, while Rod Chenos got himself an Emmy nomination leaping high in the air for the nonexistent high snap.  Unfortunately, the offense ran out of downs, on the 11 and Chenos was called out, again, for a 28-yard field goal, which narrowed the margin to one.

THIRD QUARTER SCORE:  JOHN CARROLL 28,  MOUNT UNION 27

"THESE GUYS ARE GOOD!" 

99johncarroll4.jpg (7348 bytes)     Scoring resumed, in earnest, in the fourth quarter.  Mount opened the period with a five-play 35-yard drive, with runs by Moore and a reception by # 88 Jr. Rob Sondles of Wadsworth.  Dan Pugh went spinning for the final nine yards to put the purple and white guys up by five.  Following the dictates of coaching, Coach Kehres called for the two-point play, but was seen frantically attempting to call "Time" when he saw something in the opposing alignment.  The Smeck to Marino conversion was unsuccessful.  MUC 33, JCU 28.

     This time the Mount Union lead held for 39 seconds: a kick off, and two plays later # 24 WR Jeff Lerner, a Soph. from North Olmsted/St Ignatius pulled in a TD pass from Arth.  This time the Streaks went for the "killer" two pointer and failed.  JCU 34, MUC 33.   The John Carroll lead then held for 38 seconds.  After a long afternoon of hitting the middle of the line for short gainers Chuck Moore broke one around left end and came down the near sidelines on a 66-yard-TD run.  This time the two pointer was successful to Marino, putting the teams back into scoring synch, a fact which was to extend the afternoon, considerably.  MUC 41, JCU 34.

     This time our guys held the lead for almost ten minutes, before their Larry Holmes out jumped a defender, again, to polish off an 82-yard drive, tying the score at 41, with 59 seconds left.  This time it looked like the Blue team might have scored to soon.  Mount moved the ball from their own 20 to the JCU six in seven plays using only 48 seconds, but a couple of uncharacteristic "miscues": a sideline pass to the left and a squandered timeout, placed the ball on the left hash mark with 11 seconds to go, and no time outs.   Even though there were downs remaining, the guys in white had to kick it now, as any kind of problem with a scrimmage play might end the game without the opportunity to do so.  The "spot" was a right footed kicker's worst nightmare: close in, left side and into a cross wind coming from the front and left side.  The spot was good; the hold was good; the kick was strong and looked good, till it twanged off the right upright and back onto the field of play.  The Mount side groaned; the Carroll side went nuts and the Carroll offense came out to "take a knee" and initiate what, I believe, was the first overtime for either side.

FOURTH QUARTER SCORE:  MOUNT UNION 41, JOHN CARROLL 41

GLADIATORS

     As far as I'm concerned, a regular season game should have ended at this point, as it had in two previous ties between the schools.  With the expanded playoffs, and a formalized coaches poll why risk injury to these student athletes, after they have already given their all?  Both teams had played their hearts out and both teams deserved a victory, or at least a share of one, but I don't make the rules.

99johncarroll5.jpg (6074 bytes)

     Overtime in NCAA football consists of "periods" where each team gets the ball on the opponents 25-yard line, with four downs and the opportunity to make first downs and any normal scoring play, in the regular fashion.  In today's game both teams used the East end of the field on all possessions.

     Just as the teams regrouped and took the field a colder wind hit us from behind, in the South stands.  Mount had to go first, in the first overtime.  The clock was "dark" and the "period" light read "5" I didn't know that they could do that!   Mount ran four plays and gained one yard.  Chenos came out, with the wind behind him, and made a 43 yarder, for three points.  MUC 44, JCU 41.  John Carroll now had the chance to meet or beat us.  They made one first down, but the Purple "D" held.  Their # 3 Sr. David "the Toe" Vitatoe of Cuyahoga Falls/Walsh Jesuit split the same uprights for his three.

FIRST OVERTIME:  MOUNT UNION 44, JOHN CARROLL 44

     For the second overtime the Streaks went first, and struck quickly.  On the second play, after much running around, Arth found Larry Holmes for a third time, standing in the left corner of the end zone.  The Raider defender apparently lost track of him, with the growing crowd pressing in towards the end line down there.  Vitatoe added the one-point conversion.   It was now up to the Raiders to meet or beat the new total.  The Raider offense worked methodically, no need to hurry now.  Four plays; one first down later, Chuck Moore scored his third TD of the day and Chenos added his point to retie the score.

SECOND OVERTIME:  MOUNT UNION 51, JOHN CARROLL 51

     The announcement was made that beginning with this period, teams would now be required to go for a two-point conversion, to increase the chances of a "death blow."

     It was now Mount's turn to go first: how long could this go on?  Wasmer Field has no lights and, with the later start, it would start to get dark soon.  Mount took three plays to go the 25 yards.   Smeck found # 81 Adam "Big Red" Irgang in what had been Larry Holmes' corner of the end zone, for six.  On the two-point conversion, Adam Marino was knocked flat, and Smeck's pass fell incomplete.  Marino lay on his back, still, on the turf for what seemed like forever.  The Trainers were called and finally, he was helped to his feet
and walked off slowly.  The feeling came over the Mount side that this was it.   After 45-straight wins, we would stand or fall on these six points.

     Was history on our side?   Irgang was the guy whose TD beat Carroll last year, in Alliance. 

99johncarroll6.jpg (4961 bytes)     Carroll came out, Arth under center.  On each play he seemed to have an eternity to pass - our line never caught him all day.

     First Down: Incomplete.
     Second Down: Incomplete.
     Third Down: Incomplete.
     Fourth Down: The ball is batted up and around like the end of the first half:                               finally it finds the ground.

     Exaltation and exhaustion - the Mount players and students surrounding the end zone pour onto the field, but not to tear down the goal posts - everyone wants to hug one of the guys on the field.

     What an ending.  What a relief: Times Square: "War Ends"

     No one on either side wants to leave.  After the teams line up and exchange hand slaps, almost every player on both sides is surrounded by a knot of family, friends and fans.  Up in the booth, they are already calling it "the greatest game in the history of Ohio College Football."   Certainly in the history of OAC football, if not in all of Division 3.

     Oddly, bitter rivals united in a sort of hostage psychology.

     108 total points; 1,120 total yards; 14 touchdowns: four field goals; records, statistics and "personal bests" that it will take the rest of the week to evaluate.

     Win number 46 in a row, the toughest one of them all.

FINAL SCORE:  MOUNT UNION 57,  JOHN CARROLL 51 (3 OT)

GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS: 

     The good news is that even though it's only week #4, the win should virtually assure us of another OAC "Crown," a playoff berth, with home field advantage and a first round "bye." 

     The bad news is that Carroll QB Tom Arth is only a Freshman and that we will, most likely, be seeing this team again, in late November, or early December.

     Next week: Heidelberg "under the lights" at Tiffin Columbian Stadium 7:30 P.M. kickoff.  Sorry for the length of this week's letter - the game took 3 1/2 hours.  Next week's should be much shorter.

 

Dick Ross
Class of '66

*Thank you to John Carroll University Sports Information Director Chris Wenzler for his help with this page;   photos by John H. Reed III.
        *Thank you also to Dick Ross.  Without his hard work this page would not have been possible.